‘Chicago Fire’ Fans Devastated After Two Favorites Aren’t Coming Back: “I’m Done Watching”

The wind howled through the familiar doors of Firehouse 51, but the chill had nothing to do with the weather. Rather, it was the icy shock settling over fans of Chicago Fire — a series that has held its viewers spellbound for more than a decade — as news broke that two of their most cherished heroes may soon vanish from its ranks.

After a staggering 13 seasons of blazing battles, tearful goodbyes, and unbreakable bonds, Chicago Fire now faces a crossroads that no one saw coming. According to a stunning report by Deadline, the beloved Daniel Kyri and Jake Lockett, who brought to life the unforgettable Firefighter Darren Ritter and Firefighter Sam Carver, might not return if the show is renewed for a 14th season. The reason? An unforgiving budget crunch. NBC, looking to safeguard its finances in a tightening market, may cut costs by showing these characters the door — a door fans never wanted them to walk through.

For those who’ve grown to love Darren Ritter since his first appearance in Season 7, this is a gut-wrenching development. Darren stood as a shining light in the firehouse, proving time and again that courage came in many forms, and that a kind heart could beat just as fiercely as a firefighter’s flame. Viewers watched him transform from a fresh-faced newcomer to a respected, essential part of the team — a man who put his own fears aside to save lives on countless occasions. The mere suggestion that his story might be abruptly cut short feels like an insult to all the times he risked it all.

And then there is Sam Carver, introduced in Season 11, who added a different layer of intensity to the show. Haunted by his own inner battles, Sam fought to find stability in the chaos of his life. Fans witnessed his tumultuous relationship with Violet (portrayed by Hanako Greensmith) blossom and unravel with all the painful, human realism that Chicago Fire has made its signature. Sam’s demons were raw, unfiltered — and that honesty made him relatable. His presence on-screen was like a spark in the dark, refusing to be smothered no matter how strong the winds of trauma blew against him. To imagine the series without him is to rip out one of its most complicated, compelling chapters.

Jake Lockett On His Upcoming Exit From 'Chicago Fire': Will “Miss The Hell  Out Of” The NBC Series

The blow is even harder to bear because of how sudden it all feels. There was no warning, no gentle lead-up to this moment. Instead, the news crashed down on fans like a sudden alarm bell in the night. Loyal viewers, who have stuck by Chicago Fire through the most harrowing rescues and heartbreaking deaths, took to social media in waves of fury and despair. Comments poured in, some with disbelief, others with rage, but most with deep, heartfelt sorrow. “I’m done watching,” one fan declared, perfectly summing up the grief and betrayal so many feel.

If there is a single bright spot, it’s the faint hope that their departures might not be so abrupt. Deadline reported that if these two favorites truly must leave, the show’s creators may at least grant them a proper farewell. Production is still in progress, which leaves the door slightly ajar for a powerful, dignified sendoff worthy of these characters’ courage. No fan wants to see Darren or Sam simply vanish off-screen, unacknowledged after all they’ve given. A sendoff, bittersweet though it may be, would at least offer a sense of closure — a final salute for heroes who deserve nothing less.

Jake Lockett Gets Support From Rome Flynn Following Unexpected 'Chicago Fire'  Exit: 'Grass Is Greener'

But even that small mercy feels too little, too late for those whose lives have been intertwined with Firehouse 51 for years. After investing countless hours, tears, and cheers into following Darren’s bravery and Sam’s tormented path, the thought of a forced exit is a betrayal that stings. It raises uncomfortable questions about loyalty, about whether long-time supporters of the series will stay once beloved faces are taken away in the name of money.

Of course, no series can last forever without changes. Fans know this. Cast shake-ups have happened before, and each time Chicago Fire has found a way to rally, to rise from the ashes of lost characters and tell a new story. But this time feels different. The emotional connection to Darren and Sam is so strong, so raw, that the idea of letting them go feels like cutting out a piece of the show’s very heart.

And so the question lingers, heavy as smoke in the rafters: can Chicago Fire survive this heartbreak? The creators will face a monumental challenge in trying to mend the fractured trust of viewers who feel these cuts are unfair and cruel. Perhaps new heroes will emerge, new rivalries will spark, and new romances will blossom. But the shadow left by Daniel Kyri and Jake Lockett will not fade easily.

As production pushes forward, there is still a sliver of possibility that the powers behind Chicago Fire might find another solution, another way to keep these fan-favorites alive in the narrative. After all, TV history is littered with shocking reversals, unexpected reprieves, and miraculous returns. The fans who have stuck with the show through the worst tragedies know better than anyone that hope, like a stubborn flame, is hard to extinguish.

Chicago Fire boss hints Ritter will be back for season 14 for a proper  sendoff - IMDb

Until a final decision is made, viewers will wait, nervously clinging to any shred of good news. They will dissect each scene, hunt for clues, and try to read between the lines of every official statement, desperately hoping for a miracle.

But if the worst comes to pass, if Daniel Kyri and Jake Lockett truly do bid farewell, fans will have no choice but to gather in spirit, honoring Darren Ritter and Sam Carver for the courage, complexity, and humanity they brought to the firehouse. Their legacy will burn on in the memories of those who watched them grow, fall, rise again, and fight for every life that needed saving.

Chicago Fire has always been about more than flashing lights and roaring blazes. It has been about family, sacrifice, loyalty, and love. The loss of Darren and Sam would wound that family deeply — but perhaps, in the heartbreak, there is also a chance for everyone to remember why these characters mattered so much in the first place.

And so, fans brace themselves. The alarm bells have sounded. The fire is coming — but whether it will consume these beloved characters entirely or leave enough embers to rebuild remains to be seen.

Related articles

Chicago Fire EP Reveals Finale’s #Stellaride Twist, Violet & Carver’s Uncertain Future, and Firehouse Shake-Up

When it comes to high-stakes drama and jaw-dropping moments, Chicago Fire never disappoints. The recent season finale left fans on the edge of their seats with a shocking #Stellaride…

‘Chicago Fire’ Fans Devastated After Two Favorites Aren’t Coming Back: “I’m Done Watching”

The wind howled through the familiar doors of Firehouse 51, but the chill had nothing to do with the weather. Rather, it was the icy shock settling…

Miranda Rae Mayo’s Stella Kidd Is the Leader Firehouse 51 Didn’t See Coming — But Needed Most

Stella Kidd didn’t enter Chicago Fire with a spotlight. She didn’t need one. From the moment Miranda Rae Mayo joined the series, she brought fierce fire and unexpected heart…

Chicago Fire and Real-World Firefighting in 2025: How the Show Mirrors Today’s First Responder Challenges

For over a decade, Chicago Fire has dramatized the lives of Chicago’s bravest — the firefighters, paramedics, and officers of Firehouse 51. But even as the show delivers dramatic…

Chicago Fire’s New Love Triangle? Violet & Carver Face Tougher Road Than Brett-Casey, Says Showrunner

Matt Casey and Sylvie Brett’s replacements in Chicago Fire season 13 — Violet Mikami and Sam Carver — are going through a similar predicament they previously encountered….

Women of Firehouse 51: The Quiet Power Behind Chicago Fire’s Strongest Storylines

For over a decade, Chicago Fire has thrilled audiences with high-octane rescues, emotional character arcs, and the intense camaraderie of Firehouse 51. While much of the spotlight…