Timothy Olyphant’s Forgotten Western Proves How Good Taylor Sheridan’s ‘Yellowstone’ Could’ve Been at HBO

Before things went all crazy with bunkhouses and brutal ranch politics, there was a Western that quietly did what some of the newer hits are still trying to figure out.

It starred a future cowboy icon and had all the chaos-fueled stuff you’d want in a show. It’s one of those blink-and-you-miss-it classics that proves the Western genre had legs even before streaming wars.

Frankly speaking, if this had landed on the right network with a certain big-name creator at the helm, it might’ve rewritten TV history before anyone even said “Dutton.”

Timothy Olyphant’s old western Deadwood walked so Yellowstone could run

Wild Bill Hickok and Al Swearengen in a still from Deadwood walking down the market
Wild Bill Hickok and Al Swearengen in a still from Deadwood | Credits: HBO

Before Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone turned ranch drama into a billion-dollar Western empire, HBO had already set the gold standard. Enter Deadwood, the foul-mouthed, character-packed Western that made Timothy Olyphant a cowboy icon long before he was chasing land disputes in Montana (via Screenrant).

Deadwood ran for three bloody-good seasons from 2004 to 2006 and came back swinging with Deadwood: The Movie in 2019. It never had Yellowstone‘s spinoffs or global reach, but what it lacked in franchise power, it made up for in sheer prestige.

Set in 1870s South Dakota, Deadwood leaned hard into realism. Grit, grime, and gut-punch dialogue, the kind Sheridan later mastered, were already alive and well here. With a loaded cast including Ian McShane, Molly Parker, and Jim Beaver, the series made Westerns cool on TV before it was trendy.

Deadwood paved the way for shows like JustifiedGodless, and even Yellowstone owe their boots-on-the-ground storytelling to the path it carved. Taylor Sheridan may be the king of the genre today, but Deadwood proved that Western wasn’t dead, just waiting for the right showrunner to dig it up.

Had HBO backed Taylor Sheridan early on, Yellowstone could’ve had a completely different tone, maybe even better. But what we got instead is two genre giants: one that built the road, and one that drives it full speed.

If you call yourself a Western fan and haven’t watched Deadwood yet, well… watch it, please.

Related articles

Whew!Cole Hauser’s Net Worth 2025: How Rich Is the ‘Yellowstone’ Actor?

Taylor Sheridan and the Western genre go together like peanut butter and jelly, with one only lifting the other up. Whether he is exploring blood-soaked justice in Hell…

Oop!Matthew McConaughey Leads Yellowstone Spinoff With Fresh Cast and Characters!

The Yellowstone universe is set to expand in a bold new direction, and fans are already abuzz with anticipation. After an unforgettable five-season journey, the original Yellowstone…

Just a stereotype on steroids”: Sorry Taylor Sheridan, ‘Yellowstone’ Has Already Aged Like Milk and You Can’t Even Blame Kevin Costner

Yellowstone used to be the king of TV’s Wild West, and now, it’s just a dusty tumbleweed refusing to roll off-screen. What started as a gritty neo-Western juggernaut…

Yellowstone: How Beth Dutton Became The Show’s Fiercest Weapon & One Of The Most Dangerous Women On TV

Yellowstone’s Beth Dutton became a force to be reckoned with. Read on to know our take on this complex and layered character! Right from the start, Yellowstone…

Yellowstone Is Finally Back With 8 MORE Episodes: Here’s the Complete Release Schedule!

Yellowstone Is Finally Back With 8 MORE Episodes: Here’s the Complete Release Schedule! After a nearly two-year hiatus, the Dutton family saga returns with an unexpected twist: eight…

That’s wild!You Won’t Believe Who Kevin Costner Has Dated — His Love Life Is Basically a Movie!

From world-famous supermodels to soft-spoken folk singers, Costner’s romantic history reads like a saga — full of glitz, mystery, and moments of unexpected tenderness.  Supermodels – Beauty…